Uncategorized

Too Many Books

Concerned and worried about the huge drop in registrations in a failing/failed Greek economy, reducing the number of compulsory coursebooks, workbooks and the like, is beginning to be a consideration for some foreign language school owners locally.

The parents of younger pupils can no longer afford the high cost of books – many are hard pressed to even pay tuition fees and have stopped sending their children to private language centres, contenting themselves with the lessons provided freely in the Greek state school.

In view of unemployment and of many families finding it hard to cover even their basic needs, it seems that some parents have really started to protest very seriously.

Too many books

Students from #eltpics by @yearinthelife

On August 26, 2009 and earlier on my Greek blog, I published a post (one of my first, in fact) with the title ‘How many books to teach a six year old?
If you click on that link, you will find out that, unfortunately, it doesn’t involve just one or two … .

Student’s Book – Grammar Book – Activity Book and Workbook – Video Book – Companion – Audio Book – Listening Book – eBook

This is the standard menu – even the internet needs a book!

And parents never uttered a single murmur!!!!!!

Is it the publishers’ fault?

I think it is, to a certain extent. Pandering to a book hungry market does not commend an educational publisher for educational decisions. Just like pandering to a test hungry market does not commend a testing organisation for testing very young learners…. either…

It’s time to stop  publishers from indulging the market with an this excessive and unnecessary use of multiple books where one would be more than enough.

Most  of them are filled with boring mechanistic exercises anyway – to keep the teachers  busy (lest they should have a few minutes left over and get lazy…keep ’em busy busy!!!!), and younger students  busy at home with various meaningless exercises, lest they should have some free time for  play .

One book or none at all!

I think it’s time that owners/managers/DOS’es trusted  their teachers and believed that they can teach with just one coursebook or, in some cases, with no coursebook at all!

I am certain that the quality of teaching will improve hugely, without the anxiety of having to cover  all these countless pages and without the pressure  of having to ‘to get on with the unit’.

In the case of certain franchises, whose name shall not be revealed (unless you twist my arm), all the centres must be moving in total synchronicity and be on page X on the same day!!!

Isn’t that absolutely incredible to an educator  in their right senses?

Trust in Teachers

If school managers don’t trust their teachers to do a good job, it’s their fault for hiring untrained teachers who, after 10 or 15 years of teaching have not developed the skills of pedagogy and design a CELTA graduate can master in only four weeks!

This mentality has created a generation of teachers totally dependent on coursebooks and all their paraphernalia, as well as teachers who are indifferent , complacent and who expect everything to be provided by the coursebook either because they do not know how to create their own material/activities or because, even if they do know, they are not allowed! 

I personally believe it is too late to ask these teachers to be trained now – since the very same managers discouraged them from attending courses or workshops “because none of this stuff actually works in class’, or ‘our students won’t be able to participate”, etc.

Well-trained teachers report being unable to apply what they learn in their training courses “because if you do all these activities, when will you be able to get through all these books that we have asked the parents to buy? ‘

A vicious circle of poor pedagogy which wishes good educators to perform at their worst.

I find the reaction of parents great – even if it’s for the wrong reasons.

But the decision to reduce the number of coursebooks will not be made for the right reasons by the schools either.

Related Blog Post 

Companions: an aid, a crutch or a snag? 

 

Subscribe to this Blog

If you liked this post, you might want to consider subscribing to my RSS feed to receive notifications of new posts

About the Author

Marisa Constantinides is a teacher, teacher trainer and author; she is the Director of CELT Athens, a Teacher Development Centre offering courses in TEFL. Marisa has worked with teachers in the private and state sector for many years and is an RSA Diploma holder (DTEFLA) herself; she also holds an M.A. in Applied Linguistics from the University of Reading. Find out more about Marisa here.

Categories: Uncategorized

10 replies »

  1. Great blog post! Thanks for sharing! I really like what you said about “Well-trained teachers report being unable to apply what they learn in their training courses…” I teach adults who must buy program texts, as well, and I feel guilty not using them since they had to spend upwards of 50 euro for the set. Instead of teaching the way that I want to, I must change my teaching in such a way as to incorporate the books.

    However, the thing that bothers me the most about the texts is not their price or their control over my teaching, but the fact that the language they present is so stiff and unnatural that I constantly tell the students that “real people don’t talk like this.” It would be one thing if the texts were representations of authentic language, but since they are not, we are stuck with this impossible dilemma: follow the training and sound methodology and make people upset, or follow the book and compromise your teaching.

    • Good comment, Bekha, though some of the more recent coursebooks do try to include real samples. However, I must point out that learners at lower levels cannot make sense of real, authentic, English and that it does need to be presented in a way that is accessible to them,

      Thank you for visiting here and for giving me some feedback,

      Marisa

  2. That’s a great post Marisa but you forgot the writing book, speaking book and… the test book – last year my pre-FCE students had to pay 20 € for the coursebook’s testbook and additionally 15€ for a past papers testbook Not to mention the coursebook, workbook, successful writing, companion.(Funny but sadly true!!) Thank you so much of drawing attention to such an important matter in ELT. It is important that such important people in ELT raise this issue! Thank you Marisa!

  3. I’ve never heard of such a policy as to have more than even two coursebooks for a language learning program. There’s simply no reason for it. Our programs have no assigned texts at all and they never will so long as I’m involved. Teachers and students are the best resources for material. Texts are great for filling in the gaps of these created materials. Of course, I thought everyone already knew that.

  4. Couldn’t have said it better myself! For ages now I’ve been begging to be allowed to do away with books alltogether. My colleagues look at me like an alien and criticising me for wanting to make our job more difficult! But I think I am very close to achieving my goal since some of the times I did work without the coursebook, the feedback we got from students was excellent and to top it all I felt like I had done the most wonderful lesson. I came out of the classroom feeling revived and excited as oposed to when I was forced to just do grammar, grammar and grammar again!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s