Well, I guess many educators have read this post which was sent to me via e-mail. I cannot even remember who first sent it to me. The email contained the pupil’s name but I have not published it, as I recently discovered that this was not a fictitious name but a very real one – the young man even has a facebook page!
Here it is:
Exam 1 of the 2nd term
Write an essay on the following question:
QUESTION: ‘What is a crocodile?’
Use block letters and write legibly
Name: (withheld) 11 years old
Date: MONDAY 22/05/2000
‘THE CROKODILE IS A SPECIALLY BUILT SO LONG BECAUSE THE FLATTER THE BETTER SWIMMER. AT THE FRONT OF THE CROCODILE IS THE HEAD. THE HEAD EXISTS ALMOST ONLY OF TEETH. BEHIND THE CROCODILE THE TAIL GROWS. BETWEEN THE HEAD AND THE TAIL IS THE CROCODILE.
A CROCODILE WITHOUT A TAIL IS CALLED A ROTWIELER. A CROCODILE’S BODY IS COVERED WITH HANDBAG MATERIAL. HE CAN THROW HIS TAIL OFF IF HE GETS A FRIGHT BUT IT DOESN’T HAPPEN MUCH BECAUSE A CROCODILE IS SCARED OF NOTHING.
A CROCODILE STAYS UNDER THE WATER BECAUSE IF YOU WERE SO UGLY, YOU WOULD ALSO STAY UNDER THE WATER. IT IS GOOD THAT A CROCODILE STAYS UNDER THE WATER, BECAUSE A PERSON GETS SUCH A BIG FRIGHT IF A CROCODILE CATCHES YOU THAT HE FIRST HAS TO RINSE YOU OFF BEFORE HE CAN EAT YOU.
A CROCODILE ISN’T HARDLY AS DANGEROUS AS PEOPLE SAY HE IS, EXCEPT IF HE CATCHES YOU. THE LONGER HE BITES YOU, THE MORE IT HURTS. VERY OLD CROCODILES SUCK THEIR PEOPLE AND BUCK THAT THEY CATCH DEAD.
IF YOU EAT HIM, HE IS A CROCOSATIE. A CROCODILE DID NOT LEARN TO SWIM WITH HIS ARMS SO HE USES HIS TAIL. THE LITTLE BROTHER OF THE CROCODILE IS A LIZARD. THE SLOW SISTER OF THE CROCODILE IS A CHAMELEON. THE GAY BROTHER OF THE CROCODILE IS A DAFFODIL.
AND THE CROCODILE ALSO HAS A DEAD BROTHER THE FRIKKIDEL!’
What strikes me, apart from great mirth about the images this piece of writing creates in my mind, is a number of things
1. The piece is wildly imaginative but beautifully so and, for me, climaxes with the gay brother called a ‘daffodil” and the dead brother called a “frikkidel”
2. It is structured and highly descriptive
3. It pulls together a lot of facts that the pupil half-knows, but hey, he was only 11 years old! Chapeau!!!!
and last but not least…
4. It contains very few errors of language
I do not know what possessed this boy’s teacher to circulate this homework – may be the writer is reading it today and having a good laugh himself. May be not.
I wrote this piece to express my admiration to this 11-year-old boy. I know who he is and I am going to try and find out if he has fulfilled what I think shows great promise!
Categories: Blog Post
This piece of writing is hilarious! And how creative!
My favourite part is the one about family :)))
It’s great to have bloggers focusing on Young Learners.
I’ll keep coming to your blog for more.
Greeting from Istanbul,
Hi Anita and thanks for commenting. Some people have said that this could not be a real piece of student writing. I don’t know but it’s a great read!
Greetings from Athens! 🙂